1084-1086 Bay Street 2 Retail Properties Offered at $1,850,000 in Staten Island, NY

Two meticulously maintained mixed-use masonry buildings offered together as a single investment package in the heart of Rosebank, Staten Island. 1084 Bay Street features one commercial storefront and one residential apartment offering a clean, two-unit asset with stable income. 1086 Bay Street features a commercial storefront, a rear studio apartment on the first floor, a one-bedroom apartment on the second floor and an additional unit suited as an apartment or office plus a separate leased garage with office. Five income streams under one roof. Ideally located right across from a commercial shopping center and just minutes from the Verrazzano Bridge, these properties sit in one of Staten Island's fastest growing corridors with rents that are well below market and significant room to grow. Both buildings share a private driveway leading to rear parking, adding a convenience rarely found in comparable mixed-use assets. All units are separately metered, and both buildings feature full basements. Real estate taxes and water/sewer are reimbursed by tenants, keeping ownership expenses lean and NOI strong.
Location Highlights
Rosebank, Staten Island — one of the borough's fastest-growing commercial corridors
Directly across from a commercial shopping center — strong foot traffic and retail demand
Minutes from the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge — excellent regional connectivity
Shared private driveway with rear parking for both buildings
Property Highlights
Two contiguous mixed-use masonry buildings — low maintenance, durable construction
Seven total income-producing units: commercial, residential, garage, and flex office/apt
Full basements in both buildings
All units separately metered — no utility exposure for ownership
Real estate taxes and water/sewer reimbursed by tenants in both buildings
Meticulously maintained — pride of ownership throughout
High and dry — no flood or drainage issues
Rents well below market with significant upside on renewals and lease-up