UNDER CONTRACT.
The Sale of The Former Holy Name of Mary Assumption Church Property
Property Overview:
An exceptional 3.5-acre corner property (Survey in doc file) located in the Village of Maybrook, within the Town of Montgomery. Historically the site of the Holy Name of Mary Assumption Church, this offering includes multiple structures set amid parklike grounds and features an oversized parking lot—perfect for adaptive reuse or redevelopment. Traditional Downtown Design Zoning (docs in file) Broker Access. Please allow 24-48 hours for showing confirmations. This is an "as-is, where is" sale. Prior to closing, all liturgical items will be removed from the property, including the alter, stained glass, pews, etc. All offers must be in writing with proof of funds. Church = 2,662+/-SF, Parsonage = 2,437+/-SF, Chapel = 8,289+/-SF
Improvements:
• Church building – traditional sanctuary with architectural character
• Rectory – detached residential-style structure with versatility for offices or housing
• Garage – accessory building for storage or maintenance use
• Social Hall – multi-purpose gathering facility with open floor plan
Site Features:
• Total lot area: 3.5 acres
• Excellent corner frontage and high visibility
• Expansive paved parking area
• Mature, landscaped grounds offering a serene, park-like environment
Location & Accessibility:
Situated in the Village of Maybrook within the Town of Montgomery, Orange County, NY. Minutes to I-84, I-87, Stewart International Airport, and regional shopping and services. Surrounded by residential neighborhoods, schools, parks, and municipal amenities.
Fiscal Details:
• 2025–2026 property taxes: $26,656, reflecting loss of tax-exempt status
Demographics & Market Snapshot:
Village of Maybrook
• Population (2023 estimate): ~3,147 residents
• Median household income: $89,293
• Median property value: ~$234,500
• Median age: 46.5 years
• Poverty rate: ~7.4%
Town of Montgomery (includes Maybrook & others)
• Median household income: ~$88,348 (town-wide), ~$98,360 (ACS estimate)
• Per capita income: $42,141
• Highest earning households: Ages 25–44 ($116,688), Ages 45–64 ($115,385)
Major Employers & Economic Drivers
• Local logistics/distribution: FedEx, Home Depot, XPO, Staples, ShopRite, Instacart
• Regional presence: Amazon, UPS, USPS, Dollar General, Target, McDonald’s
• Historical hub: Maybrook Yard, transportation & warehousing corridor
