Share This Listing

Message

963 characters remaining

Hmm, there seems to have been an error sending your message. Please try again.

Your email has been sent.

Still interested?

Contact the broker for more information about this property

Investment Highlights

  • Strong investment opportunity offering multiple buildings, warehouse space, established tenants, and flexibility for owner occupancy.
  • Ideally located in a scenic and historic coastal community, this property offers strong business functionality, ample parking, and access to a vibrant
  • Central location - limited commercial properties available on the island, cmoes with grease trap, grill and walk in refrigerator.

Executive Summary

25 West Neck consists of 3 single and separate buildings -
Building 1 - consists of 2 retail spaces - 48 x 34.2 with basement. Two separate furnaces and two 275 gallon tanks.
Two tenants occupy this building - Tenant 1 is a bagel company occupying 1,655 sq ft front entry with 7ft overhang porch. Full Board of Health Approval, New air Conditioner/Heater 2018, Industrial Exhaust 2020, Fire Suppression System., Walk-in refrigerator, Grease Trap 2024, Enclosed Trash Area.
Tenant 2 is currently configured as a Dog Grooming Business - the new tenant of this space is going to renovate and turn this space into a construction office.
Building 2 - consists of 1 retail space - 24.3 x 33.5 - has its own furnace and fuel tank. This space was occupied until recently by a hairdresser.
Building 3 - consists of one large warehouse space with a drive-thru electric door, pad dumpster, six inch concrete floor and 100 amp power source. This could serve as a storage unit or an operational garage.

Attachments

25 WNR Full FP

Property Facts

Sale Type
Investment or Owner User
Property Type
Retail
Property Subtype
Freestanding
Building Size
6,630 SF
Building Class
C
Year Built
1974
Price
$1,875,000
Price Per SF
$282.81
Percent Leased
66%
Tenancy
Multiple
Building Height
1 Story
Building FAR
0.42
Lot Size
0.36 AC
Zoning
B - Business District see attached list of uses many uses under the zoning, 3 buildings, retail, office, warehouse
Parking
10 Spaces (1.51 Spaces per 1,000 SF Leased)
Frontage
60’ on west neck rd
Somewhat walkable
20/100
Exceptionally drivable
90/100
Fairly bikeable
40/100

Nearby Major Retailers

IGA
Chase
  • Listing ID: 40622591

  • Date on Market: 5/21/2026

  • Last Updated:

  • Address: 25 West Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Link copied
Your LoopNet account has been created!

Please Share Your Feedback

We welcome any feedback on how we can improve LoopNet to better serve your needs.
X
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.starRating, "rating") }}
255 character limit ({{ remainingChars() }} charactercharacters remainingover)
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.msg, "rating") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.fname, "first name") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.lname, "last name") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.phone, "phone number") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.phonex, "phone extension") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.email, "email address") }}