37 Old Route 9W - 27 & 37 Old Rt 9W, St Thomas Church 2,430 SF Specialty Building Offered at $825,000 in New Windsor Township, NY 12553

Rand Commercial is pleased to present the exclusive offering of 27 & 37 Old Route 9W -- a historic church campus situated on 3.20+ contiguous acres in the Town of New Windsor, Orange County, New York. The property is owned by The Episcopal Diocese of New York and represents a rare opportunity to acquire an irreplaceable 1847 stone Gothic Revival church, meeting hall, and residential dwelling on a commercially zoned parcel with prominent Old Route 9W frontage and sweeping Hudson River views.
Zoned Neighborhood Commercial (NC) by the Town of New Windsor, the site accommodates a broad range of permitted uses by right including places of worship, professional offices, retail, eating and drinking establishments, and service businesses. The property is offered strictly as-is, where-is. Qualifying nonprofit or municipal purchasers may be eligible to restore the previously held tax-exempt status, which could significantly reduce long-term carrying costs.
PROPERTY SUMMARY
Address 27 & 37 Old Route 9W, New Windsor, NY 12553 Municipality Town of New Windsor, Orange County, New York
Tax Parcels Parcel 1: 9-2-7.1 | Parcel 2: 9-2-7.2 Property Type Religious / Institutional
Zoning NC -- Neighborhood Commercial (Town of New Windsor)
Total Land Area 3.20+ Acres (Two Contiguous Parcels)
Total Building Area 7,558+ SF Gross (Three Structures) Interest Offered
Fee Simple Estate Sale Condition As-Is, Where-Is -- Both Parcels Together Asking Price $825,000
Flood Zone Zone X -- Outside Floodplains (FEMA Panel 36071C0332E, 8/3/2009)
Utilities Municipal Water & Sewer Deed Restrictions None noted adversely affecting value Sales History No known sales or transfers within prior 5 years Leases No leases in place/.
Fee Simple, unencumbered Current Tax Status Tax-exempt status lapsed 2025; may be restored for qualifying nonprofit or municipal buyer.
Please use our offer form at the end of the Offering Memorandum with proof of funds.