BluePearl Pet Hospital 4706 New Horizons Blvd 32,000 SF Office Building Appleton, WI 54914 $7,500,000 ($234.38/SF) 7.87% Cap Rate

INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS

  • BluePearl Pet Hospital – Prime Core+ Investment Opportunity
  • Institutional-Quality Tenant and Operations
  • Significant Upside Potential and Value-Add Opportunities
  • Stable, Near-Term Cash Flow with High Growth
  • Premier Class A Medical Facility in a High-Growth Market
  • Re-tenanting opportunity: Strong demand from 50+ major healthcare operators in Wisconsin

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

BluePearl Pet Hospital – Prime Core+ Investment Opportunity

Presenting BluePearl Pet Hospital, a premier STNL investment opportunity at 4706 W New Horizons Blvd, Appleton, WI 54914. This Core+ asset, located in a growing, high-demand market, provides immediate cash flow stability with substantial long-term upside potential and promising forward-looking assumptions.

Stable, Near-Term Cash Flow with High Growth:
- NNN lease with 4.5 years of remaining term
- Fixed 2.00% annual rent escalations and below-market rent
- Two (2) five-year renewal options at fair market rent

 Institutional-Quality Tenant and Operations:
- BluePearl Pet Hospital (Mars-owned, S&P A+ rated parent company)
- Established presence with a strong financials
- Extensive referral network (240+ referring veterinarians across WI and northern MI)
- Experienced veterinary team (19 veterinarians on-site with an average tenure of 10-15 years)
- High caseload: 120-150 ER cases and 30+ surgical cases per week

 Premier Class A Medical Facility in a High-Growth Market:
- State-of-the-art facility built by Boldt with significant reinvestment from tenant and landlord
- Strategic location with major roadway access and strong surrounding amenities
- Growing population and above-average median household income
- Only 24-hour specialty and emergency vet hospital in the region (next closest: 100+ miles away)

 Significant Upside Potential and Value-Add Opportunities:
- Adaptable for any medical use
- Multiple end of lease value-add opportunities in 2029:
- Fair market renewal: Potential $190,500 NOI increase (option Year 1 NOI: $821,500)
- Blend and extend: New 10- to 15-year lease structure

Re-tenanting opportunity: Strong demand from 50+ major healthcare operators in Wisconsin

PROPERTY FACTS Under Contract

Sale Type
Investment
Property Type
Office
Property Subtype
Medical
Building Size
32,000 SF
Building Class
B
Year Built
2003
Price
$7,500,000
Price Per SF
$234.38
Cap Rate
7.87%
NOI
$590,069
Tenancy
Single
Building Height
2 Stories
Typical Floor Size
16,000 SF
Slab To Slab
12’
Building FAR
0.15
Lot Size
5.00 AC

AMENITIES

  • Signage

PROPERTY TAXES

  • Listing ID: 35335160

  • Date on Market: 4/1/2025

  • Last Updated:

  • Address: 4706 New Horizons Blvd, Appleton, WI 54914