Share This Listing

Message

916 characters remaining

Hmm, there seems to have been an error sending your message. Please try again.

Your email has been sent.

Still interested?

Contact the broker for more information about this property

Middle Island Plaza 846-900 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island 86,118 SF 75% Leased Retail Building Middle Island, NY 11953 $17,500,000 ($203.21/SF) 6.45% Cap Rate

Save this listing!

Favorite this listing to get notified of price updates, new media and more

Investment Highlights

  • For Sale: Middle Island Plaza Retail Center
  • 3,500 SF Drive-thru Pad Site is Available and Approved to be Built on the Property
  • 772 ft of Frontage on Middle Country Rd
  • Consisting of Several Retail Tenants - Majority on Long-Term Leases
  • Most Tenants have Options to Extend
  • Ample On-Site Parking with 380 Spaces

Executive Summary

American Investment Properties is retained to sell the property located at 846-900 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island. At this location is a large retail neighborhood center consisting of several tenants. Most tenants are on long-term leases with options to extend. There are currently 2 vacant spaces that provide for great lease-up opportunities. This property has vast frontage on Middle Country Rd and ample on-site parking for the convenience of shoppers.

Data Room Click Here to Access

Property Facts

Sale Type
Investment
Sale Condition
Lease Option
Property Type
Retail
Property Subtype
Storefront
Building Size
86,118 SF
Building Class
B
Year Built
1983
Price
$17,500,000
Price Per SF
$203.21
Cap Rate
6.45%
NOI
$1,128,207
Percent Leased
75%
Tenancy
Multiple
Building Height
1 Story
Loading Docks
3 Exterior
Building FAR
0.15
Lot Size
13.00 AC
Zoning
Commercial
Parking
380 Spaces (4.41 Spaces per 1,000 SF Leased)
Frontage
772’ on Middle Country Rd

Space Availability

  • Space
  • Size
  • Space Use
  • Position
  • Available
  • 864
  • 15,000 SF
  • Retail
  • In-Line
  • Now

Former Middle Island Rite Aid store Available for lease. This 15,000 Sq. Ft. space is available for immediate lease. Space includes 1 Drive in Bay, two bathrooms and a large open floor plan.

Space Size Space Use Position Available
864 15,000 SF Retail In-Line Now

864

Size
15,000 SF
Space Use
Retail
Position
In-Line
Available
Now

864

Size 15,000 SF
Space Use Retail
Position In-Line
Available Now

Former Middle Island Rite Aid store Available for lease. This 15,000 Sq. Ft. space is available for immediate lease. Space includes 1 Drive in Bay, two bathrooms and a large open floor plan.

Nearby Major Retailers

Bank of America
Toyota
Gold's Gym

Property Taxes

Property Taxes

Parcel Number
0200-403-00-02-00-002-001
Land Assessment
$8,000
Improvements Assessment
$49,130
Total Assessment
$57,130
  • Listing ID: 39416086

  • Date on Market: 2/12/2026

  • Last Updated:

  • Address: 846-900 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, Middle Island, NY 11953

Link copied
Your LoopNet account has been created!

Please Share Your Feedback

We welcome any feedback on how we can improve LoopNet to better serve your needs.
X
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.starRating, "rating") }}
255 character limit ({{ remainingChars() }} charactercharacters remainingover)
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.msg, "rating") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.fname, "first name") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.lname, "last name") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.phone, "phone number") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.phonex, "phone extension") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.email, "email address") }}