907 N Pennsylvania St
Indianapolis, IN 46204
Downtown Retail - Office w/Parking · Property For Lease

COMMERCIAL FREE-STANDING PROPERTY IN THE HISTORIC ST. JOSEPH NEIGHBORHOOD Nestled on the northeast side of downtown Indianapolis, in the charming St. Joseph historic district, this unique building offers a blend of character, history, and functionality. The property encompasses two buildings (901-907 N. Pennsylvania St.) with a fully fenced 20+ space parking lot and a tenant-controlled gate for secure and convenient access. A PROPERTY WITH A STORY 907 N. Pennsylvania St., a 1,189 sq. ft. free-standing building (40.69% prorata share), was originally built as a Toddle House in the late 1930s. This quick-service, 24/7 restaurant was known for its always-available breakfast and distinctive cottage-style architecture, featuring a vibrant blue porcelain tile roof that made each location instantly recognizable. KEY AMENITIES & FEATURES ON-SITE PARKING – A rare 20+ space, fully fenced lot with a tenant-controlled gate, plus metered and free side street parking. HIGH-VISIBILITY LOCATION – Located on a major thoroughfare downtown with great daily foot and vehicle traffic. SIGNAGE & BRANDING OPPORTUNITIES – Prime street frontage offering maximum visibility. WALKABILITY & NEARBY AMENITIES – Close to a multitude of restaurants, coffee shops, hotels, and businesses. EASY HIGHWAY ACCESS – Quick connectivity to I-65, I-70, and the rest of the metro area. PUBLIC TRANSIT ACCESS – IndyGo bus stops nearby for added accessibility. This property is an ideal opportunity for those seeking a commercial space rich in charm, well-positioned, highly visible, and easily accessible, with its own private, gated on-site parking in a neighborhood with a rich architectural history.