Share This Listing

Message

959 characters remaining

Hmm, there seems to have been an error sending your message. Please try again.

Your email has been sent.

Still interested?

Contact the broker for more information about this property

Middle Island Plaza 2 Properties Offered at $15,500,000 in Middle Island, NY

Save this listing!

Favorite this listing to get notified of price updates, new media and more

INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS

  • Ron Kleinberg, President of Tri-State Properties, has been retained as the exclusive selling broker for the property.
  • Email: rkleinberg@tri-stateproperties.net
  • Phone: 516-818-5626

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
Middle Island Plaza is an 82,000 SF supermarket-anchored neighborhood shopping center prominently located at 846–900 Middle Country Road, Middle Island, NY. Built in 1983 and situated on 13 acres, the center offers exceptional visibility, strong daily traffic, and convenient access with 380 on-site parking spaces.
Anchored by established national retailers including AutoZone, Bank of America, and Tutor Time, the plaza is further supported by a mix of local businesses that cater to the surrounding suburban community. The asset is being offered at $15,500,000, reflecting a current actual cap rate of 6.5%.
Middle Island Plaza also presents a compelling value-add opportunity with approximately 22,000 SF of additional leasable space, including an approved 4,050 SF pad site, providing upside through future leasing and expanded tenant mix.
Exclusive Representation:
Ron Kleinberg, President of Tri-State Properties, has been retained as the exclusive selling broker for the property.
For further information or to pursue this opportunity, please contact:
Ron Kleinberg
Tri-State Properties
Phone: 516-818-5626
Email: rkleinberg@tri-stateproperties.net

PROPERTY FACTS

Price $15,500,000
Price / SF $168.48 / SF
Cap Rate 6.50%
Sale Type Investment
Status Active
Number of Properties 2
Individually For Sale 0
Total Building Size 92,000 SF
Total Land Area 15.70 AC

PROPERTIES

PROPERTY NAME / ADDRESS PROPERTY TYPE SIZE YEAR BUILT INDIVIDUAL PRICE
Middle Island Plaza
856-900 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, Middle Island, NY 11953
Retail 82,000 SF 1983 -
846 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953 Specialty 10,000 SF 2016 -
Show More > < Show Less
  • Listing ID: 39053193

  • Date on Market: 1/12/2026

  • Last Updated:

  • Address: Middle Island Plaza, Middle Island, NY

Link copied
Your LoopNet account has been created!

Please Share Your Feedback

We welcome any feedback on how we can improve LoopNet to better serve your needs.
X
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.starRating, "rating") }}
255 character limit ({{ remainingChars() }} charactercharacters remainingover)
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.msg, "rating") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.fname, "first name") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.lname, "last name") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.phone, "phone number") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.phonex, "phone extension") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.email, "email address") }}